Thursday, May 29, 2008
This is for You, Mormon
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
5/29/2008 05:10:00 PM
0
comments
Wednesday, October 31, 2007
Evolution as Fact and Theory
There were few scientists as capable as Stephen Gould at conveying subtle, complicated ideas in clear prose accessible to the lay reader. In 1981, he took on the nascent "creationist" cabal, then boosted by the imbecile Reagan. Before shredding their pseudo science, he demolished their strawman -- that evolution is "only" a theory:
In the American vernacular, "theory" often means "imperfect fact"—part of a hierarchy of confidence running downhill from fact to theory to hypothesis to guess. Thus creationists can (and do) argue: evolution is "only" a theory, and intense debate now rages about many aspects of the theory. If evolution is less than a fact, and scientists can't even make up their minds about the theory, then what confidence can we have in it? Indeed, President Reagan echoed this argument before an evangelical group in Dallas when he said (in what I devoutly hope was campaign rhetoric): "Well, it is a theory. It is a scientific theory only, and it has in recent years been challenged in the world of science—that is, not believed in the scientific community to be as infallible as it once was."-- Stephen Jay Gould, Evolution as Fact and Theory (1981)
Well, evolution is a theory. It is also a fact. And facts and theories are different things, not rungs in a hierarchy of increasing certainty. Facts are the world's data. Theories are structures of ideas that explain and interpret facts. Facts do not go away when scientists debate rival theories to explain them. Einstein's theory of gravitation replaced Newton's, but apples did not suspend themselves in mid-air, pending the outcome. And humans evolved from apelike ancestors whether they did so by Darwin's proposed mechanism or by some other, yet to be discovered.
Moreover, "fact" does not mean "absolute certainty." The final proofs of logic and mathematics flow deductively from stated premises and achieve certainty only because they are not about the empirical world. Evolutionists make no claim for perpetual truth, though creationists often do (and then attack us for a style of argument that they themselves favor). In science, "fact" can only mean "confirmed to such a degree that it would be perverse to withhold provisional assent." I suppose that apples might start to rise tomorrow, but the possibility does not merit equal time in physics classrooms.
Evolutionists have been clear about this distinction between fact and theory from the very beginning, if only because we have always acknowledged how far we are from completely understanding the mechanisms (theory) by which evolution (fact) occurred. Darwin continually emphasized the difference between his two great and separate accomplishments: establishing the fact of evolution, and proposing a theory—natural selection—to explain the mechanism of evolution. He wrote in The Descent of Man: "I had two distinct objects in view; firstly, to show that species had not been separately created, and secondly, that natural selection had been the chief agent of change. . . . Hence if I have erred in . . . having exaggerated its [natural selection's] power . . . I have at least, as I hope, done good service in aiding to overthrow the dogma of separate creations."
(A tip 'o the hoagie to Talk Origins Archive)
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
10/31/2007 06:16:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: Intelligent Design, Religion
Friday, September 07, 2007
MoJo: Jesus, Hillary
"Through all of her years in Washington, Clinton has been an active participant in conservative Bible study and prayer circles that are part of a secretive Capitol Hill group known as the Fellowship. Her collaborations with right-wingers such as Senator Sam Brownback (R-Kan.) and former Senator Rick Santorum (R-Pa.) grow in part from that connection."
The rest is here.
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
9/07/2007 03:08:00 AM
0
comments
Sunday, April 08, 2007
Get Thee Behind Me, Christian
Please keep your pathological mythology out of my face, my government, my life.
This time of year, the arrogance of the christianista is patent . . . . everyone passing through the checkout line, swiping a passcard, swilling a Manhattan (up), wolfing down a chicken cesear, is assumed to be a fellow traveller. This display is tempered only by those who chirp "happy holiday" when one takes one's leave, instead of "happy easter". (Oh, I know that passover is coincident with easter this year. But that's only convenient cover for them -- if passover were last week, the bag boys would not have been commanding shoppers to 'enjoy the holiday'.)
The truth assumed by these chirping retail clerks is that everyone passing their way shares the same demented beliefs. Depending on mood (or Manhattans swilled) I alternate between head-patting sympathy and screaming resentment.
But when the religionistas inflict themselves on my society, on my government, what I feel welling up is more of a nose-crunching swing. Over the last decade, the question of the religious beliefs of politicians has moved from the subtle, whispered observations, mainly launched to disqualify non-christians, to overt examination in the popular press. Along with trend comes the candidate anxious to get earn their religious street cred.
I watched the '68 race pretty closely -- watched Nixon roll over his primary challengers, which included several-term Michigan Governor George Romney. George being Mitt's father, the current Governor Romney seeking the current Republican nomination. If, during the '68 campaign, I learned that G. Romney was a mormon, it is a fact I long ago forgot. (What I didn't forget was that G.Romney was born in Mexico. Does that make Mitt . . . .?)
I need to work before I can take seriously a candidate -- particularly one who wants to be President -- who is a devout anything. Any person who professes belief in an invisible man in the sky, who insists that their personal morality is dictated by fairly convoluted scribblings jotted during imagined conversations with the invisible man millennia ago, and who truly believes that the only best purpose of "earthly" existence is to grease the slide for the "real" life on the "other side", is not, to me, someone I want, with a pious finger on the button, leading the greatest (if declining) military and economic power in the world.
Give me Presidents like Washington, Lincoln or Jefferson, who joined no cult of mythology, or even Adams, who thought the most sacred beliefs of christians pretty silly and had a somewhat Machiavellian view of religion's utility on controlling the mob. But spare me the politician anxious to prove their ignorance and thoughtless supplication to this evolutionary byproduct.
Get thee behind me, christian. And get out of my government.
Adams might have been right, although I have my doubts, that religious beliefs are useful for controlling the passions of the mob. But religions increasing role in my government has no salutary upside. The current regime has successfully created an office dedicated to funnelling money to prop up religion, has outlawed support for legitimate scientific inquiry based purely on religious dogma, and has even created the absurd situation where park rangers at the Grand Canyon have to avoid denying that the canyon was created by Noah's flood.
When irrational belief informs public policy, and devotion to irrational belief is a de facto requirement to run for President, we are all fucked.
Nero, play on.
Additional Reading:
First Freedom First
Blog Against Theocracy
Blue Wren: The golden rule . . .
Progressive Historians: These Are the Fruits of Theocracy
Culture Kitchen: Warren Chisum and Women Who "Try Things on Their Own"
Bring It On!: What Would the Prince of Peace Think of the Price of War?
Bring it On!: Theocratci Street Gangs
NYTimes: Darwin's God
Hullabaloo: God's Law, Never Man's
Pandagon: The tightrope of keeping religion out of politics
Blue Gal: A memo to non-believers
Pew Forum: Religion and Politics
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
4/08/2007 06:48:00 AM
4
comments
Labels: First Amendment, Religion
Wednesday, January 03, 2007
Why Hasn't Pat Robertson Been Confined?
"Robertson said God spoke to him during his annual [!?] one-on-one prayer retreat with the Almighty." Who could say such a thing and not have their competence questioned? Instead, it is the subject of "serious" news reporting:
The TV preacher claims the Lord told him to expect a terrorist attack on the United States by the end of 2007 that will result in "mass killing." "I'm not necessarily saying it's going to be nuclear," Robertson said yesterday . . . . "The Lord didn't say nuclear. But I do believe it will be something like that," said the 76-year-old preacher and one-time presidential candidate.
And let's not get started on the caring, loving god of the christians, who revels in blood, gore and unleashing evil:
"God said he's going to restrain the evil, but he isn't necessarily going to restrain it in the beginning," Robertson said.Why is this guy walking around free -- On November 7, 1999, on his TV show, he supported armed rebellion against the United States:
Ladies and gentlemen, I want to say this very clearly. If the people of the United States of America . . . decide that they're not going to allow the Supreme Court to dominate their lives . . . . [t]hey are not going to be able to overturn the will of a hundred million American people. And I think the time has come that we throw off the shackles of this dictatorship that's been imposed upon us. We had a war in 1776 that set us free . . . . And I think the time has come that we do that.But no one raised a voice to question his sanity, or his patriotism, even Newt Gingrich was silent. And then, of course, there was his big hit -- god made 9/11 happen to punish us for hurting god's feelings. This is the same christianista who advocated assassination:
[Y]ou could send a squad in to take out somebody like Osama bin Laden, or to take out the head of North Korea, but isn't it better to do something like that, to take out Milosevic, to take out Saddam Hussein, rather than to spend billions of dollars on a war that harms innocent civilians and destroys the infrastructure of a country?(I guess George wasn't listening to that last part.) But, at least Robertson is enlightened on equal rights for women:
The feminist agenda is not about equal rights for women. It is about a socialist, anti-family political movement that encourages women to leave their husbands, kill their children, practice witchcraft, destroy capitalism, and become lesbians.Oh. Nevermind, then.
(Photo credit: El Nuevo Cojo Ilustrado Media LLC)
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
1/03/2007 06:19:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: Christianistas, Religion
Sunday, December 31, 2006
Sadly, This Didn't Surprise Me
Washington, DC — Grand Canyon National Park is not permitted to give an official estimate of the geologic age of its principal feature, due to pressure from Bush administration appointees. . . . “In order to avoid offending religious fundamentalists, our National Park Service is under orders to suspend its belief in geology,” stated PEER [Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility] Executive Director Jeff Ruch. “It is disconcerting that the official position of a national park as to the geologic age of the Grand Canyon is ‘no comment.’”The report goes on to discuss that, after rejecting dozens of scholarly scientific books and articles for sale at the Grand Canyon National Park, the sole new item approved for sale was a book claiming that the Grand Canyon was suddenly cut out into the earth by Noah's flood.
(h/t to A Spork in the Drawer)
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
12/31/2006 02:23:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Christianistas, GWB, Howz That?, Religion, Science
Monday, December 04, 2006
More Bigotry from the Right
In an incredibly stupid and grossly misleading column, wingnut Dennis Prager shits himself over the Congressman-elect's desire to swear his oath on a book that means something to him -- the Koran. In doing so, he gets almost everything wrong -- he falsely says this will be the first time anyone has ever taken the oath on anything but a bible, he falsely says that "America" decides what book an lected official can swear on, and he can't stop before trudging out the Hitler comparison and wondering 'if the Koran is okay, what's next, Mein Kampf?' I am not going to link to this loser asshole's tripe -- you can find it if you really want to poison your mind with it.
Better, take in Sean Aqui's smackdown of Prager.
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
12/04/2006 05:17:00 PM
1 comments
Labels: First Amendment, Religion
Thursday, November 30, 2006
Stupid
Trautman put aside all the unimportant issues facing his Church, to issue an edict that, while allowing the show to go on, precludes the kids from telling anyone the name of the show they are promoting is, gasp, Urinetown.
Nice object lesson for these high school kids.
What a moron. (Oh, boy, just wait until he hears about the plan to screen one of Kevin Smith's movies during Senior Week.)
(photo credit: AP/Reed Saxon via Chieftain.com)
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
11/30/2006 07:06:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Religion
Sunday, September 24, 2006
The Fool on the Hill
Most of you who read this blog on a semi-regular basis (that would make it two people) are familiar with the Santorum Blog. It is officially unaffiliated with, but very supportive of, the floundering campaign by Virginia's third Senator to keep his seat.
It is run by AlexC, who is, to all appearances, making a real effort to bring some quality to that site. He provides a great deal of information about the latest buzz, on the news and opinion front, on issues related to the contest between Santorum and Casey. There are others on the staff, who contribute on an irregular basis, of differing levels of quality and rabidness, but none of whom present themselves in nearly an admirable way as Alex. Some of them are thoughtless and shrill in their cause. Those members of the crew pepper the Santorum Blog with unsupported assertions, unsourced "facts", and not infrequent ad hominem attack when refutation grounded in fact and logic lays beyond their grasp.
And so it is with this latest entry by one of the lesser minds on the Santorum Blog who sought to rush to the defense of our Great Decider from a post of mine that, interestingly enough, consisted largely of direct quotes from Commander Codpiece and absolutely no commentary from your ineloquent Slob.
The dust-up was occasioned by a series of quotes which I have been running in the "Howz That" sidebar for two or three weeks. Replacing them over the weekend, I saved them for posterity in this post (which was birthed mostly as an excuse to run this post).
What I learned about myself from this attack was remarkable. (As was the attack's headline, suggesting that any linkage between Bush and God was fearmongering. Leaving aside for the moment that I am of the devout opinion that any influence of religion in our government is something worthy of fear, for a far-right bushlapper to make the same connection is truly worthy of remark.)
I am "misquoting people and making stuff up" (my quotes were direct and linked to their sources).I had not realized just how an incompetent fraud I have been. And here I was going to the trouble of linking to my sources and researching them a few hours each post when apparently all I need to do to sustain my opinons is refer to the little voices in my head. Oh good, now I can stop taking that medication, too -- there's another couple hundred bucks a month saved!
It appears that I believe that "Bush is a Christofascist lunatic who . . . wants to kill everyone who doesn’t convert to Methodism". I haven't been able to find that argument in any of my posts, but I am subject to the periodic blackout, especially on weekends, so if anyone can help me find it . . . . ("Christofascist"?!)
Apparently, I don't do "the slightest bit of research". That's actually good to hear because in the morning I am going to call Lexis\Nexis and tell them they are going to have to eat that bill they sent me because obviously it wasn't me using their service. While I am at it, I might as well cancel my subscription to the service, that'll save me a nice bunch 'o bucks every month.
There's more, too, and here's how I responded on the Santorum Blog site (from which I am getting even MORE hits thanks to this):
Well, thanks for paying attention and confirming that the quotes are embarassing to any rational person.
But nothing you say to refute them is correct.
You say “in order to help promote his and most hysterical liberals’ idea that Bush is a Christofascist lunatic who I guess wants to kill everyone who doesn’t convert to Methodism”
I have never made any such claim and neither know nor care of the identities of the others with whom you desperately try to lump me. Of course, in keeping with the pattern of shrill denial, there are no links to the source material on which you rely.
You then say “he cites a pair of discredited Bush quotes“. Two lies here. One, I provided more than two quotes from Bush, the others you ignore, but more on that presently. The second lie, unsourced, as usual, that that the quotes have been discredited. To the contrary, despite repeated requests, the White House has refused to deny the quotes — nor confirm them — as the Washington Post reported here. This last cite ties in to your overarching lie — false, unsourced, allegations that I have misquoted, made things up, and not researched what I say. To the contrary, everything in MY post is sourced and the quotes are correct.
Thus, when you say “It’s easy to see how Abbas and Shaath just completely made these quotes up if you do the slightest bit of research. Not that the left would bother to double-check anything which is anti-Bush, but still.” You again fail to source the easy research you did. Instead, you rely simply on your own opinion, falsely presented as fact. But, here in the real world, we do not cite to the voices in your head.
Your statement about any claim that Bush said God wanted him to steal oil for Haliburton is simply bizarre. I never said anything like that (indeed I said nothing — I simply posted the quotes simpliciter, sans commentary). But, once again, you rely on misleading your reader to make a point.
Your statement that “Bush allegedly made these statements during a meeting with various Middle Eastern leaders on June 4, 2003, in Aqaba, Jordan“. Is likewise false, but necessary to set up your crushing blow: “Thanks to WhiteHouse.gov, we have a full transcript as well as a full audio clip from the meeting.”
If you had bothered to read the reports, to which I linked as my source material, you would have learned that these comments were made in a private meeting among Bush, the Palestinian President and Palestinian Foreign Minister, for which we have only the — highly detailed — minutes of the Palestinians, which formed the basis of the reports that I cited. The White House has refused to release its memoranda on the meeting, has refused to deny the comments, and has refused to comment on the report (as the Washington Post article said).
Your comment “That’s just as bad as saying that God told you to kill Muslims” once again suggests something I never said. Of course, we are not given the link to your source for my supposed comment.
You suggest that it would be obvious why the Palestinians would make up the quotes (which the White House has refused to deny). But that statement is rather ignorant of the political situation. Here we have a President who has made clear his commitment to the re-establishment of a Palestinian state — which is the goal of the Palestinians. If the quotes were intended to place Bush in a poor light, what would the Palestinians gain from antagonizing the person who is supportive of their ultimate goal? It is hard to see who gains by the fabrication of the quote.
But what is revealing are the two quotes which you ignore — one from a group of Amish with whom the President met, in private, and the other from one of his closest friends:
“I trust God speaks through me. Without that, I couldn’t do my job.”
– President Bush (July 2004). Here he was speaking with a group of “Old Order Amish”. Once again, no reason to suspect that a group of Amish men, women, and children, had anything to gain by fabricating this quote.But then we have the comment from Bush’s very close personal friend which, as is the Amish quote, similar to and in the same vein as the (un-denied) quotes to the Palestinian leaders:
‘Bush believes he was called by God to lead the nation at this time’.
– Commerce Secretary Don Evans (April 2004)
These last two comments are entirely consistent with the thoughts expressed by the first two — this President is a man who actually believes that he has been divinely selected. That consistency of thought process, and the White House refusal to deny the Palestinian minutes of the private meeting, as well as the lack of any profit to the source of fabrication, led me to conclude, after my research, that I had a legitimate basis for posting the quotes. Of course, what you completely ignore is the much more important theme — that when a man believes, as completely as this President so obviously does, that he has the invisible man in the sky behind him, that “God speaks through me”, he not only has little reason to question what he does, his theology would suggest that questioning what he does would be near heresey.
And that is the dangerous situatiuon which my six quotes, posted without commentary, intended to convey.
You are entitled to your own opinion, but not your facts. And you are less entitled to falsely and without basis disparage the integrity of someone with whom you disagree. But that last point is one far lost on this Administration and many of their blind faithful. Thankfully, today those are a small minority.
I recall a time when Bill Buckley would sit down with people who disagreed with him, nearly every week, and have a rational, thought-provoking, and respectful discussion (well, except for that unfortunate encounter with Gore Vidal). The ability of people to disagree honesty and respectfully seems to be on the wain, and that's unfortunate. It is a development not unrelated to the alacrity with which critics of this Adminstration's policies ( even if calling them "policies" gives them a false implcation of resulting from careful thought), are so quick to be tagged as disloyal and compared to Nazi sympathesizers.
Back when I was a practicing attorney, an older lawyer wisely advised me that, if your opponent is a fool and the argument empty, never say that. Instead, he told me, skewer them with fact and reason -- lead the court to "discover" the vacuity of the argument for itself. If they discover it for themselves, they will own it forever.
Of course, that advice never works if you are the fool.
UPDATE (09/25/06): As if attempting to prove that he is indeed the fool, John Lewandowski has posted an update on his main post which is typical of his retreat from truth, logic, and fairness. The intended impact is to discourage his readership to actually read my response to his lies:
Naturally I would forget to mention that all of this is quite similar to what Santorum’s critics are doing to him with his book, “It Takes a Family”. If Bush and Santorum are so evil, why do they need to be attacked with years-old quotes, second-hand alleged “quotes”, and out-of-context distortions of what they actually said or wrote?The first paragraph is just silly (as if the whole thing weren't) -- Santorum is running for reelection based on his record of bushlapping. He and Bush are issues in this election. I guess this clown would have us ignore what they have said. The remainder of that paragraph once again falsely says that something was misquoted, without a link to any source showing that to be so (the voices in his head approach to proof).
The Slob defends the integrity of the second-hand Abbas and Shaath quotes in the comments. His acceptance of the suspect quotes seems to be based upon a misreading of his sources and a general misunderstanding of Christianity. Well, I guess we really shouldn’t expect a leftist to understand the Christian faith, so we can let that slide.
The second gaf is yet another astounding descent into intentional dishonesty to hide personal failure. What I questioned was the source of this fool's claim that the comments were discredited. After I pointed out that Bush had refused to deny them when given the opportunity, I guess the best he can do is to now change the argument to yet another false claim. (Can anyone say "WMD"?)
Finally, once again, I said nothing about christianity (and remind you that I said nothing in my original post -- I merely posted the quotes without commentary) -- I was talking about a President who has said -- and has been quoted by close personal friends as saying -- that god selected him the way god selected Moses, and that he is doing god's bidding. As if thinking that he is talking to an invisibile man in the sky wasn't enough of a worry when the man has his finger on the button, Bush not only believes that god speaks to him, but that he is doing god's work.
As I mentioned, he posted this non-update as a response to things I didn't say, not in reply to my post, but on the front page. Obvioulsy the intention was to discourage his fellow travellers from reading the detailed response. Not only is this John Lewandowski person a liar, he's also a wimpering coward.
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
9/24/2006 11:25:00 AM
2
comments
Saturday, September 23, 2006
With God on His Side
-- President Bush (July 2004)
"God told me to strike at al Qaida and I struck them, and then he instructed me to strike at Saddam, which I did, and now I am determined to solve the problem in the Middle East."
-- President Bush (June 2003)
"I'm driven with a mission from God. God would tell me, 'George, go and fight those terrorists in Afghanistan.' And I did, and then God would tell me, 'George, go and end the tyranny in Iraq . . .' And I did. And now, again, I feel God's words coming to me, 'Go get the Palestinians their state and get the Israelis their security, and get peace in the Middle East.' And by God I'm gonna do it."
-- President Bush to Palestinian Leaders (June 2003)
'Bush believes he was called by God to lead the nation at this time'.
-- Commerce Secretary Don Evans (April 2004)
"You never ask questions when God's on your side."
-- Bob Dylan (April 1963)
"Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by the rulers as useful."
-- Seneca the Younger (5 BC - 65 AD)
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
9/23/2006 09:53:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: GWB, Howz That?, Religion
Wednesday, September 13, 2006
With God on Our Side
"George W. Bush says he decided to seek the presidency only after hearing about how God chose Moses to lead his people to the promised land." -- God is Their Co-Pilot, by Jake Tapper, Salon.Com
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
9/13/2006 05:13:00 PM
0
comments
Sunday, August 13, 2006
Pure Evil, Incredible Violence
It is Fidel Castro's 80th Birthday. Thanks to the American politics of the post-revolution era, American School children never learned the real stories behind the 1959 overthrow of Batista. Instead, for generations it was enough to label Castro a "Communist Dictator", as if that said everything we needed to know. We were neither a Communist nor a dictatorial society, so painting Cuba as a Communist dictatorship made it obvious -- Cuba bad, US good. This myopia combined with blinders, ironically, opened the way for glorification of Castro and his right-hand in the revolution, Che Guevara.This unintended consequence of the American tendency to rewrite history, censor open discussion, and prefer easy labels, is unfortunate. College students have, for decades, declared -- and still declare -- their dissent with one of the popular high-contrast drawings rendered from Alberto Korda's famous photo of Che (reprinted above). This is unfortunate because Che and, even more than Fidel, his more aggressive and brutal younger brother, Raul, were extremely brutal and cruel. They were particularly cruel to their own subordinates during the revolution. Che executed, or had executed, underlings for a wide variety of transgressions, from suspicion of passing information to the Batista regime to drunken insults. One example.
In 1958, Che had a devoted lieutenant serving under him -- Armando Rodriquez. Armando was older than Che, but looked to Che as a wise leader and, as important, social philosopher. Armando's son, a 16-year old firebrand named Israel Pardo Rodriquez. Che was moving his forces westward towards Mt. Turquino to meet up with Fidel, when two of his troops has deserted with their weapons. After a fruitless chase of the two, Che learned that the two had previously been involved in marijuana trade with Israel and another of his group. Suspecting that the four had planned to raid a nearby marijuana farm and desert, he ordered Israel and the other to chase after the two deserters, not expecting them to return. After they left, Che learned of a wider desertion plan among his men and suspect Israel and the other three as being the leaders in the plot.
As it happened, Israel returned alone, having been separated from his companion. Che summarily tried and condemned Israel. Che assigned Armando to carry out his orders. Armando begged Che to relieve him of the assignment to execute his own boy, but Che was unmoved and demanded that Armando prove his loyalty. Tears in his eyes, Armando tied his son to a stake, placed a hood over his eyes, and prepared to fire the fatal shot when, at the last moment, Che stopped him. In effect, Che told the shaken man that he was merely testing his loyalty and had already received evidence clearing Israel of any complicity.
This was an extreme and cruel ordeal for the old man and his son. No man who could order such a thing can be even remotely considered a man of peace or love, or even sane. It is pure evil and unspeakably cruel to test a man to the limit in this way and to forever undermine a young son's faith and confidence in the love of his father. Not to mention putting the young man through the psychological ordeal of a faux execution
Over this last week, especially, numerous Bush Administration representatives, apologists and stand-ins have repeated the latest talking points on the war on terror by labeling their enemy as "Islamic fascists", as pure evil. Many have gone so far as to assert that Islam is a religion of violence. On Hardball Friday, one even proudly preferred her own "peaceful" Christian religion to the "violent" religion of Islam. We've heard similar claims from this Administration and their defenders before. Ann Coulter speaks of the godless liberals and proudly proclaims her devotion to the god of the bible. But the god of the bible is an infinitely more evil and murderous entity than even Che and Fidel. While I don't know much about Islamic beliefs, or the Quar'an, I find it hard to believe that it could be any more violent and evil than the bible.
I apologize, dear reader, for the ruse. But the story of Che and Armando and Israel, while using actual historical events, is otherwise false. Che never made any such order to Armando or anyone else. Che was indeed a cruel and harsh leader, but not as cruel and harsh as to demand a father execute his son to prove his loyalty. But, as you've deduced by now, that story is familiar to all of you -- it is the bibical myth of god and Abraham. Armando is Abraham and Israel is his son, Israel, whom god commanded Abraham to sacrifice for no reason other than to demonstrate Abraham's commitment to god.
Such is the face of the god of the bible. It is a god who is incredibly cruel, violent and evil. The bibical god appears to enjoy death, blood, and destruction. According to the bibical mythology, that god killed 70,000 (innocent men) because King David decided to take a census of the Israelites: "So the LORD sent a plague on Israel, and seventy thousand men of Israel fell dead." (1 Chronicles 21:14). David, and his family, were spared. But the god of the bible thought it just to kill 70,000 innocent for David's transgression.
The god of the bible wiped away the residents of 60 cities -- men, women, and children -- so that the Israelites could plunder and take the livestock, possessions, and towns for themselves. He sanctions the killing of all men and non-virgins in a town to provide a stock of virgins to serve as forced breeders for his people and, when that isn't enough, the kidnapping and rape of even more virgins. (Judges 21). This god and Jesus endorse killing children for cursing their parents (Matthew 15), and they apparently enjoy the sounds of babies being bashed on rocks (Isaiah 13:15-18, Hosea 13:16, Psalms 137:9). Revelations glories in the coming blood bath.
By some reckonings, the bibical myths recount god directly killing over 370,000 and ordering the murder of nearly 2 million more. (We haven't even touched on how the bible endorses slavery and the selling of one's own daughters into prostitution.) And christians are labeling Islam as a violent religion?
The Bush Administration has moved the enemy from Al-Qaeda and Osama bin Laden, both having grown stronger and further from our reaches since September 11, to evil doers, to haters of freedom, to Islamic extremists, and, finally, to "Islamic fascists". The formulation of this label for our enemies leads directly to the conclusion that the earliest of the post-9/11 Bush labels, quickly withdrawn, was no slip of the tongue.
You will recall that, shortly before invading Afghanistan, Bush called his war on terrorism a 'Crusade'. Nice touch -- shortly before going to war with an Islamic state, a President who hastens to publicly claim his christianity in word (but not in thought, action, or policy) uses the one term that will remind everyone of one of the most violent wars in history, perpetrated by christians against muslims in the middle east. He quickly withdrew the comment but, in fact, it revealed his true mindset -- when this administration speaks of terrorism, they mean Islam.
By reducing the enemy to the label "Islamic Fascists" they need say nothing more to create the unspoken conclusion -- they are evil, we are good, and therefore our war against them is good. Like the "Communist Dictator", the "Islamic Fascist" label advances the unspoken premise of the conclusion -- they are evil not only because they are fascists, but also because they are not christians.
With this latest turn of a phrase, Bush and Rove and Cheney are giving cover to bigots everywhere who are anxious to parrot Coulter and Pat Robertson and declare all who disagree with them evil:
Q -- Are churches that don’t agree with your politics or religious beliefs not really churches?
Coulter -- Correct: They’re called “mosques.”
Television evangelist Pat Robertson yesterday described Islam as a violent religion bent on world domination . . . . In mid-September, he and fellow evangelist Jerry Falwell sparked controversy by suggesting on the same show that abortionists, feminists, gays and liberal groups were partly responsible for the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. . . . Islam, [Robertson] concluded, "is not a peaceful religion that wants to coexist. They want to coexist until they can control, dominate and then if need be destroy."The Administration's "Islamofacists" labels give cover to Robertson and others to continue with those kinds of hateful attacks. Each time a bushite repeats the lie that the terrorists attack us because we are free and they hate freedom-loving peoples, they give credibility to truly evil people, like Coulter and Robertson -- and at the same time distract attention from their horribly-failed policies and strategies, their lies, and lack of ideas. (Anyone who believes that they hate us for our freedom is either ignorant or a liar; the Bush administration would do well to spend some time learning exactly what Che's revolution was about and how a moderate, middle-class doctor became the icon of 20th Century revolutionary movements.)
When you strive so hard to create that kind of divisive atomosphere, when you legitimize hateful attacks on people who are not-christian, or not-white, or not-whatever-you-are, you also give cover to other expressions of bigotry and hatred -- such as against brown people who risk life and limb for a few dollars more, or against those who oppose the failed policies of the administration.It is hard to recall when it has been so acceptable, in our so-called tolerant and pluralistic nation, to attack those who disagree, those who dissent, those who are in the minority, those who are different, as it is today. This so-called christian president bears great responsibilty for that. (Cheney image stolen from Jesus' General.)
It is a true threat to our liberty. As despicable events and their hateful statements pile up, I cannot help but suspect that 9/11 became, for this cabal, the perfect excuse to wage this divisive war against America and the liberties -- the freedoms -- that they do, in fact, hate.
View blog reactions
Posted by
A Big Fat Slob
at
8/13/2006 09:18:00 AM
1 comments
Labels: Religion




