Friday, September 22, 2006

Important New Rasmussen Polls Get it Right!

The last couple of days have seen the polls coming in fast and furious. Rasmussen has released the results of yet two more new and extremely important polls on an issue of vital national concern.

They are polls which I have scrutinized VERY carefully and determined that the respondents got it 100% correct. Actually. these polls were released at the end of August, but somehow I missed them.

The first poll reveals that, in the considered and respected opinion of baseball fans, the Yankees were the number one selection of baseball fans to win this year's World Series.

The second poll shows that 52% of baseball fans expect the Yankees to "Meet the Mets" (cute, but the Yankees don't need a ditty to attract fans) in the 2006 World Series, setting us up for the second Subway Series in this young century.

More important -- a majority of those fans understand that the Yankees will crush the overachievers from Queens ("Queens?! What kind of baseball team comes from a town named "Queens"?!), again.

Thursday, September 21, 2006

More PA-Sen Polls -- Casey Lead Firm

Rasmussen has released the latest PA-SEN poll, but only for premium members. Apparently Bob Geiger is one, or knows someone who is a premium member. He tells us that Rasmussen's September 2006 Poll calls it Casey by ten points over Santorum, 49-39%, and Pollster.com features the same numbers.

What's it all mean? Geiger agrees with us:
Santorum is toast. Even if the Santorum team Photoshops a picture of Casey marrying a gay couple, while performing an abortion, with a burning flag in the background -- and I think we know, with Republicans, that's not out of the question -- this seat goes to the Democrats on November 7.
PoliticsPA has a report on a new IssuesPA/Pew Poll which it says was released today showing Casey up by 21 points, 52-31%.

Curiously, based on a poll said to show Casey with a much larger advantage, PoliticsPA thinks the race might still be up for grabs:
Among the three-quarters of registered voters who say they are “absolutely certain” to vote, Casey’s margin actually increases by two points (55 percent to 31 percent).

The Senate race remains more “up-for-grabs” than the polls indicate, as Casey has yet to seal the deal with voters. Only one-third of Casey supporters support him strongly (17 percent of all voters), while more than two-thirds are not strongly committed to his candidacy (36 percent of all voters). That leaves some opportunity for Santorum to close the gap, and a high percentage of voters remain undecided.
I think that's overly optimistic for the incumbent. Santorum is seeking election to a third term and simply does not have a strong case to make for himself. When a multi-term incumbent's two main strategies are to bring in a siphon (Romanelli) and to weaken Casey support with attacks, AND when he is struggling to stay above 40% within 50 days of election day -- he is fighting a lost cause.

Santorum's support will begin to crumble (even more) and become more fragile the closer we get to election day. He will lose by double digits.

But don't worry, he'll be fine. He'll make more money at Haliburton anyway.

Rendell's Approval Remains High

Here's why Lynn Swann isn't getting any traction -- the latest SurveyUSA numbers for Governors are out and Ed Rendell is in the top twenty with an impressive approval rating of 60%. That mark is near the 62% approval rating he scored in May, his best rating this year. His disapprovals are down to near their lowest level this year also -- at 37% in September, he's only one point off his low of 36%, hit a few times this year.

Check Your Voter Registration

From today's in-box, a note from the folks at MyDem.org with some useful links -- check your voter registration for accurracy at their site:

Republicans stole the elections of 2000, 2002, and 2004 through dozens of dirty tricks - before, during, and after Election Day - to make sure Democratic votes did not count.

It's time for Democratic voters to fight back!

MyDem.org was created to give Democratic voters the tools we need to make sure our votes count - so Republicans never steal another election!

1. Register My Vote

Are you registered? Are you sure? Your recent application may have been lost or rejected - or your past registration may have been purged.

"Google" your registration to find out!

If you are not registered to vote, register here

In 2000, Florida illegally purged 57,000 voters - mostly Democrats
2. Cast My Vote

Avoid long lines and hackable machines - vote absentee (Rules vary by state)

The YANKEES WIN!!!

No, I am not referring to their clinching their 9th straight Division Title last night.

They have won the contract for the AAA franchise in Moosic, PA (just north of Wilkes-Barre). Since my business brings me to Wilkes-Barre quite often, and certainly more than it brings me to the Yanks' former AAA home in COlumbus, O., this is exciting news, hot off the wire. They beat out crosstown rival Mets, who were looking to move their AAA franchise closer to home from its current spot in Virginia. It's not the first time they beat the Mets this year and, if it is another Subway Series, it will not be the last!!

Latest Keystone Poll Has Casey Increasing Lead

The September Keystone Poll shows Democratic contender Bob Casey Jr. increasing his lead over incumbent Republican Rick Santorum to seven points. The poll, taken September 13-16, 2006, shows Casey beating Santorum 45% to 38%, with Green Party candidate Carl Romanelli taking 5%. The August Keystone Poll had it 44-39-4 for Casey-Santorum-Romanelli.

The Poll was taken after Santorum began running his scandalous and misleading attack advertisement against Casey and following over a month of heavy Santorum advertising buys across the Commonwealth. Sanotrum's blitz appears to have had no positive effect on his standing in the polls, with the incumbent firmly entrenched at or below the 40% mark.

Also having no effect on this race is Green Party candidate Romanelli. He is on the ballot thanks to the financial and logistical support of Santorum faithful. The Santorum campaign encouraged their followers to give money and time to the Green Party petition drive. The floundering farrr-right-wing Republican had hopes of the liberal Romanelli pulling enough votes away from the right-leaning Casey to give the Senator a shot. That didn't work, either. The latest Keystone Poll puts the race not far from where it was last summer, when the June Keystone Poll put Casey in the lead, 44-37%, with 19% undecided.

Keystone reports that 63% of respondents say that they have made up their minds and are certain of their support. Of the 37% who say that they might change their minds before election day, 14% are leaning towards Casey, 19% Santorum, and 5% Romanelli. I guess the remainder are hopelessly clueless.

As, it appears, is the Senator. Despite his heavy advertising on the immigration issue, the Keystone Poll finds that only 5% of respondents view that as the most important issue this year, behind Iraq, the economy, terrorism, health care, and "something else". Santorum's fervent support for the Bush war and economic policies obviously leave Pennsylvania voters cold. In this latest Keystone Poll, the multiterm Senator's unfavorable ratings are the highest they have ever been since Keystone began polling the Senator. Thirty-seven percent of Pennsylvanians have an unfavorable view of Virginia-based Santorum, with only 36% saying they have a favorable view of him. In June 2005, when the Poll results were about the same between Casey and Santorum, 42% had a favorable view and only 26% had a negative opinion of the job their junior Senator was doing.

While the Senator is making no headway getting voters to come over to the dark side, Casey is not ramping up his poll numbers, either. The Senator is stuck below 40% because his far-right-wing policies are so well known and his joined-at-the-hip support for the President firmly rejected. Casey is the obverse of that coin -- he isn't known and he isn't going to great lengths to make himself known. This gives the Senator his opening and his only, desperate hope -- if he can't make them love Rick Santorum, maybe he can make them hate Bob Casey.

Back in June, 2005, the Keystone Poll reported that 40% of respondents had a favorable view of Casey, 9% unfavorable. An incredible 51% didn't know -- incredible because Casey had been on the statewide ballot every second year for the last decade. In the latest poll, Casey's favorable rating has shrunk to 29%, the people having a favorable view of the challenger has risen to 22%, with 49% still not knowing how they feel about him.

With Santorum fading, expect to see more of Santorum spreading venom against Casey in the final weeks of his final Senatorial reelection campaign.

In the last 6 to 8 weeks, the Senator has reportedly spent away all of his cash lead over Casey, with the result that his position in the race has worsened, as has his favorables. Although there is over a month until election day, only an unusual event will turn this around for the Senator and we are now expecting Casey to win by double digits on election day.

In the Governor's Race, Rendell is still mopping the floor with Swann, leading 52-34% with 74% saying that their minds are made up.

Tuesday, September 19, 2006

Suvery says . . . .

"Bush still sucks!" At least in the opinion of 59% of Americans and 60% of Pennsylvanians, according to today's Survey USA poll results. With only 1% of Pennsylvanians unable to make up their minds -- the lowest figure all year -- 60% of Pennsylvanians disapprove of the decisions of this decider. This is up a point from last month, while his approval rating of 39% is down a point from the August tally.

Playing with the numbers, 52% of Pennsylvanians identifying themselves as regular church goers thinks this President is doing a lousy job -- that's a two-point "gain" from a month ago. In the largely rural "T", it has been over a year since the President has had a positive ranking from those voters. In July, 2005, 49% of voters in the T approved of GWB's job performance, 48% gave him a negative score. Apart from that, the one-third of the state's voters in the "T" -- generally considered more conservative -- have regularly, month-in and month-out, declared their disdain for the competence of the Republicans in control of Washington.

This is not good news for Virginia's third Senator who has been a loyal supporter of Bush's failure in the Middle East and elsewhere. He has, indeed, supported the President more than 98% of the time. His numbers should be out in a couple of days. Last month was the first time this year that Rick Santorum did not end up as one of the ten worst Senators (he was in a 4-way tie for 83rd), as rated by their own constituents -- including a run from April to July as THE worst Senator in the nation. I guess if he came out as "only" the 75th worst Senator in America, he'd see that as an improvement.

Monday, September 18, 2006

Romanelli Gets PA Supreme Court Review

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court agreed on Friday to hear the appeal of Green Party candidate Carl Romanelli. The appeal is limited to the issue whether the "2005 Judicial Retention Election or the 2004 General Election constitutes 'the last preceding election in which State-wide candidates were voted for' under 25 P.S. § 2911(b)."

The Supreme Court did not set an argument date, but did direct the clerk to set an expedited briefing schedule.

(h/t Politics PA)

Romanelli on PCN -- See it Now.

Green Party candidate for the US Senate, Carl Romanelli, was on the PCN-TV call in show on September 12. I missed it live and haven't had a chance to review the entire program yet. If you'd like to watch it, you can do so here. I'm not sure how much longer it will be available; PCN doesn't keep their stuff up through the entire election cycle.

I'm hoping Larry Smar will watch it, since he thinks Santorum and Romanelli stand for the same thing. (Okay, I know he doesn't truly believe that -- but that's the lie he's promoting. I'm not sure if it would be worse if he was really stupid enough to believe that, or if he thinks other people are stupid enough to believe it.)

(PS -- If you'd like to see PCN leave its election-related coverage up though the election, please join me in suggesting that to them here.)

Sunday, September 17, 2006

Blog o' the Week - Lehigh Valley Ramblings

This week, we're suggesting that you take a look at Lehigh Valley Ramblings. The proprietor 'o that blogspot is Bernie O'Hare, who claims to be a former lawyer and a current title searcher in, well, the Lehigh Valley. Bernie makes his home in Nazareth.

His blog does exactly what one looks to blogs to do -- he covers the courthouse and political scene in his corner of the universal with a pleasing mix of information, insight, and crankiness. He skewers his subjects with a clear eye and sharp tounge.

Lehigh Valley Ramblings is on my daily reading list and you just may find yourself making it a habit as well.

Saturday, September 16, 2006

Romanelli - I'll "Clean Casey's Clock" in Debates

Casey campaign chief Larry Smar says Casey won't take part in the debates because Romanelli "is a representative of the Santorum campaign." Romanelli, for his part, says Casey is “not policy-equipped and he’s a terrible debater . . . .Why on earth would he want to go up against me? Because I’ll clean his clock!”

Smar's comment is (take your pick) silly, sophomoric, a lie, cynical. Romanelli makes a couple of good points in his. I can't recall any debate in his career in which Casey came out on top -- and his clock was cleaned in the primary (worse in the two primary debates for which he showed than in the ones for which he stayed at a fundraiser in Chicago, or California, or wherever he was hiding from his opponents).

It is inappropriate for Casey to continue to duck debates. Romanelli is a candidate and deserves to participate. Casey should stop his tiresome whining about how Romanelli became a candidate and just get on with the race. Santorum's placement of Romanelli on the ballot was the cynical, inappropriate, and desperate action of a losing candidate. Casey's cynical, inappropriate, and desperate attempts to avoid debating Santorum and Romanelli pegs him as a loser, regardless of the outcome of the vote.

Friday, September 15, 2006

Another Friend of Rick's Sits in Jail

Rick Santorum wants people to judge Bob Casey by his supporters. He's recently run an advertisement featuring donors to Casey who are under investigation for various degrees of alleged wrongdoing -- all occurring after they donated to Casey. Santorum's slimy ad doesn't mention that all of the donations were years ago -- in prior Casey campaigns; that one of the men has been dead for two years; or that two of them also gave to Santorum.

So, we thought it appropriate to take a look at some of Rick's Friends, since, according to Santorum, we should judge him by their character.

Here's another one. John Rigas, as slimy and crooked as they come. He founded Aldephia Communications. He and his son (the apple falling not far from the road) were convicted in 2004 in a multiBILLION-dollar fraud which resulted in the destruction of Aledphia Cable. The Rigas Crime Family was found guilty on 18 counts of fraud and conspiracy.

They had been charged in 2002 with, among other things, conspiring to hide $2.3 billion in Adelphia debt, stealing $100 million, and lying to investors about the company's financial condition. The Rigases had effectively used Adelphia as their personal piggy bank to pay for luxury condos and a golf course, to cover personal investment losses, and to pump over $175,000.00 into their personal PAC -- the Adelphia Communications Corporation PAC.

The senior Rigas got 15 years in a federal pen; his spawn, 20.

Pretty unsavory clan, these Rigases.

But not too unsavory for Rick Santorum. He's gratefuuly shovelled about $15,000 of the Rigas PAC money into his pockets -- including $5,000.00 in this election cycle. Amazingly, the Adelphia PAC is still doling out the Rigas money (almost all of its funds came from the Rigases before they were indicted and the PAC has not received any new contributions for a few years).

And Rick Santorum, knowing that that money was stolen from Adelphia in a collapse which left it's investors -- large and small -- holding the bag, gleefully accepts the Rigas largess. Imagine that, Rick's takes money from convicted felons -- the very money they were convicted of stealing.

And that's not all, folks.

The Rigases also threw over $40,000 into the National Cable & Telecom PAC before the feds caught up with them -- and half of that money went to none other than Our Rick.

Yes, as Rick's hero says, 'Hypocrisy is good for society'. Well, for High Society at least.

Thursday, September 14, 2006

Friends of Rick Santorum

Since Rick Santorum thinks you should be judged by the people who have suppported you in the past, we're going to start a series of posts about Rick's Friends. Here's one, and now another:

Former Santorum Aides Charged in FEC Ethics Complaint

(Ed. Note: This is a story we first ran on May 21. We're rerunning it now in honor of Santorum Inc's most recent descent into desperation.)

Two former aides to Rick Santorum have been charged with multiple violations of the Federal Election Campaign Act in connection with their PAC and contributions, including to Santorum's campaign. In a five-count complaint filed by the Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington ("CREW"), Santorum's aides are alleged to have violated disclosure requirements, campaign contribution limits, PAC contribution limits, and solicitation regulations.

In February, 2001, John Dick and Joseph Kuklis, formed the lobbying company, GSP Consulting Corp. (GSP), to assist technology companies, non profit organizations and commercial real estate developers identify, chase and secure sources of government funding. Dick has deep ties to Santorum. Immediately before forming GSP, Dick was a Deputy Campaign manager for Santorum's 2000 re-election campaign. Kuklis was Deputy State Director for the same Santorum campaign.

GSP operates out of the same office building as Santorum's Pittsburgh operations and has managed to secure for its clients some $35 million in appropriations, according to an April 2006 report by the Philadelphia Inquirier.

CREW is a progressive not-for-profit with a history of filing ethics complaints against some of the more excessive or outrageous practices of (mostly-Republican) members of Congress. It was formed in 2001 by Melanie Sloan, a former aide to Democratic Representative John Conyers and Democratic Senator Charles Schumer.

(Ed. ps: Now, what does this story and the new Santorum advertisement remind me of? Oh, yeah, that's right:

"[H]ypocrisy can often be a social good.” -Rick Santorum, It Takes a Family, p. 280)

Wednesday, September 13, 2006

Abbott and Costello Take to the Road

Get ready, Pennsylvania, the odd couple of Keystone politics is planning a road trip. Carol Romanelli, who never had a viewing from the QEFTSG fellas, claims that he and Your Rick are taking to the streets.

"We will travel from Erie to Philadelphia and everywhere in between," Romanelli said. "The senator has assured me he will go forward in debate, even in the absence of Bob Casey's willingness to participate."

But not so fast, I feel a qualification coming . . . .

"Sen. Santorum looks forward to joining with Mr. Romanelli and Mr. Casey for a series of debates between now and Election Day," Davis said, adding that the details are still being determined.

(h/t to Santorum Blog.)

And, be sure to check out their offical home page.

OT: Advice to PA PoliBlogs (and others)

FIRST, no matter HOW enticing or cool it looks

DO NOT SWITCH TO BLOGGER BETA!

Google has messed with the data organization on the feeds and many third parties are unable to read them. BloggerHelp ignores pleas and message board postings on the subject. Since I made the change, LeftyBlogs can't read my feed. Technorati had problems as well, but they have a larger force than LeftyBlogs and were able to make the adjustments. Others have had problems such as blogs disappearing; archive links no longer working; problems posting comments; problems signing in; and difficulty receivign comments from others. (Meanwhile, anyone who knows of an alternative to LeftyBlogs, lemme know. I am not holding my breath for Google to fix their crap and LeftyBlogs' one-man show seems a bit o'erwhelmed by all this.)

Second, BlogRolling is having trouble seeing updates on many blogs. Their Help people have been responsive and are trying to figure it out. In the meantime, you might want to consider manually pinging BlogRolling periodically (here). That way, you'll get noticed when folks like me who have their Blogroll set to move recent updates to the top 'o the list.

We now return you to your regularly scheduled mayhem . . . .

With God on Our Side

"George W. Bush says he decided to seek the presidency only after hearing about how God chose Moses to lead his people to the promised land." -- God is Their Co-Pilot, by Jake Tapper, Salon.Com

One I Missed

In doing my overview of how various blogs treated the fifth year anniversary, I missed one of the best. It comes from a non-political blog, which is perhaps why I overlooked it that day. It is smart, funny, moving, and oh, so true.

From Liam McEneaney:

HAPPY SEPTEMBER 11TH EVERYBODY!

I was watching Meet the Press Sunday morning, and Tim Russert was interviewing Dick Cheney, and to give Russert full credit, he was not letting Cheney slide. In fact, Russert might be the only person in the press who I've seen interview Bush and Cheney and not give them softballs or easy questions. And I think that the reason he can get away with it is that the core constituency that Bush and Cheney should be afraid to alienate are not spending their Sunday mornings watching Meet the Press.

I have to say that watching Cheney cemented exactly the thing I admire most about him. I'd tried to figure it out for years, and it became crystal clear: He is not afraid to be what he is; an openly evil puppetmaster pulling the strings. I used to watch Disney cartoons, wondering why no one suspected the main villain was up to no good, what with their wearing dark capes, laughing maniacally at the slightest provocation, and singing songs about how much better life would be once the hero was dead and the world was under their thumb.

In fact, if I was going to make a movie about a bent, twisted villain super-genius bent on world conquest, I would cast Cheney in a heartbeat. You know, like the kind of man who shoots his friend in the face and gets the victim to issue a public apology for embarrassing him. The kind of man who could watch the biggest terrorist attack on US soil in history, and immediately start the wheels spinning, figuring how to turn that into an excuse to attack Iraq, a country that had nothing to do with it.

And the fact that he makes no bones about who he is is the masterstroke. If he had any kind of positive charisma, he would be the most dangerous man in America, if not the world. Instead, he's a cantankerous, contemptuous cesspit of sarcasm and bilious spittle who can go on a show like Meet the Press and be confronted with his lies, and not only show no remorse, but lie about the fact that he had lied, denying it with the fervor of a six year-old, with his hand in the cookie jar, denying that he was trying to eat a cookie.

At one point, Russert showed videotape of Cheney lying which Cheney had just lied about not having done, and Cheney immediately started adding a third lie to the mix about how the first two lies were invalid.

Cheney's at the point where I would immediately suspect him, even if he said something I wholeheartedly agreed with. If Dick Cheney went on national television and said, "The President and I are firmly against baby-eating," my first thought would be, "What's he hiding on the baby-eating issue? Do babies really taste like chocolate? Are they an alternative energy source?"

Sorry, I really try to keep politics off of this blog, but I've been surprised at how depressed I've been this whole weekend leading up to the fifth anniversary of September 11th, and to see this smug arrogant piece of left-over Nixon White House garbage telling me that his underlings hadn't spent a lot of time linking Saddam hussein to the falling of the World Trade Center makes me as sick as their use of the September 11th tragedy as political currency in the first place.

It's like the murderer who uses his lousy childhood as an excuse for his crimes. Ugh. Sometimes I expect Cheney to turn into a bat and scream, "SO LONG FOOLS! NOW I SHALL FEED ON THE BLOOD OF VIRGINS!" as he flaps off into the sunrise.

My point is, if you disagree with me, good. Please persuade me that I live in a world where the Bush administration's actions over the last five years are rational, well-reasoned, and ethical. That thousands of young Americans and tens of thousands of Iraqis didn't die in vain. That global warming is a myth, that the economy is rebounding, that the evidence of my senses are completely wrong.

In other words, I need to get laid. Okay, I get it.

Slate Senate Scorecard Shifts Slightly to Republicans

Slate's latest analysis of the Senate races sees 46 going or leaning Democratic, 50 Republican, and four tossups. Yesterday, Rasmussen identified six tossups, including Tennessee and Ohio. In Tennessee, Slate has it leaning Republican, but with momentum to Democrat Harold Ford. Slate puts Ohio in the Leaning Dem category. They see Pennsylvania as solid Dem, giving Casey a double-digit advantage (50% - 38%) based on their 5-poll average.

Slate excludes internet polls from its polling analysis. This means that two most recent Zogby Polls are not included in their 5-poll average. Regardless, the results would be the same. As the Pollster polling data indicates, including the internet polls, the 5-poll average still results in a double-digit lead for Casey, 41%-40%.

Tuesday, September 12, 2006

Rasmussen Balance of Power -- Tossup

Rasmussen's latest Senate Balance of Power Report was released today. With Maria Cantwell (D) now polling with a double-digit lead, Rasmussen has moved Washington from the Leans Democratic to Democratic column. By Rasmussen's count, 49 States are in their Republican/Leans Republican tally, 45 are listed as Democratic/Leans Democratic, and six are tossups ---Tennessee, New Jersey, Rhode Island, Ohio, Missouri, and Montana. Rasmussen places Pennsylvania in the Leans Democratic category. (Rhode Island's primary is today (get the results here).) For a change in control of the Senate, the Democrats would have to win Pennsylvania (the only "Leans Dem" Republican seat), and each of the tossups.

Casey Lead Down in New Zogby Poll

Among the things we ignored on yesterday's anniversary . . . .

A Zogby online poll taken over the holiday weekend shows Santorum's support virtually unchanged from a month ago. However, Casey's numbers drop from 51% to 47%. The MOE is 3.3, potentially putting this race at a virtual dead heat -- according to Zogby, at least. (Statisticians will also tell you that, aside from the dead heat possiblity, the MOE could well mean that the "real" numbers are 50-40.)

I am guessing that there is some skewing in here due to the holiday weekend and (perhaps) increased involvement of Republicans in the Zogby survey. Crosstabs are not available, but Zogby has taken the unusual (for them) step of using spot telephone checks to verify information provided by the online poll takers. According to the Zogby special methodology report issued with its news release, they attempted to contact about 2% of the online respondents.

I am on their online interactive polling list and was invited to participate in this poll. I did not because, well, it was the holiday weekend and I just didn't make the time. But, it is unlikely that I would have given them a correct phone number (if they asked for it) when I registered. It was even more unlikely that I would have been around to answer the phone over the Labor Day weekend (unless they paged me at Yankee Stadium). I suspect that I am not unusual in that regard.

As to increased Republican involvement, I have no evidence, only anecdotal reports of solicitation of conservatives to participate in electronic polls. This should not affect the polling if Zogby correctly adjusts the results to properly balance the results to reflect the Commonwealth electorate at large. But, since the WSJ/Zogby polls don't give the essential data, we have no way of knowing.

As a general matter, I don't have any less faith in the accuracy of interactive online polls. Many of the allegations about the efficacy of online polling were also asserted against telephone polls. However, I am always troubled when the crosstabs are not provided, as here. It is also curious that Zogby took the additional step of issuing a special methodology report with the press release. It suggests to me that there is an issue with the polls which they are trying to address.

These results don't trouble me terribly. Santorum has not made any meaningful progress in his numbers since the start of the campaign. Although he has moved from polling in the upper 30s to the low 40s, he can't win with 43%.

Not to put too fine a point on it, if Santorum were the challenger, I'd say he was in good shape. But he is a multi-term incumbent. He is tied at the ideological hip with the President, who is given very low marks in Pennsylvania. His personal favorable/unfavorable has been the worst, or near the worst, of all US Senators for over a year. A huge chunk of Pennsylvanians see this country as headed in the wrong direction -- which is the very direction in which Rick Santorum has been going. Finally, Santorum has eeked out an entire 1% increase in his polling numbers after reportedly blowing several millions of dollars on an intensive early advertising buy -- wiping out his cash advantage for the rest of the run in the process. Mabel, keep that butter handy.

That said, Casey had best soon figure out why he isn't wiping the floor with Santorum.

Monday, September 11, 2006

9/11/06

From Firedoglake -- How Did We Get from 9/11 to Iraq?:



From Dependable Renegade, Up on the Roof:
On September 11, 2001, I was sitting in my apartment on the border of Chelsea and Greenwich Village, reading my email before going out for a run down to Battery Park. I was in the middle of returning a message when I heard the scream of plane engines overhead. As a New Yorker, you tend to tune out most of the sounds of the city, but this was so loud and so close that I thought, "this can't be good." (more)
Shakespeare's Sister:
I've been sitting here thinking exactly what to say about the five-year anniversary of 9/11, and I realized there's nothing I could say about how I'm really feeling that wouldn't be crass. The truth is, I'm angry. I'm angry that it happened, I'm angry about the immediate response, I'm angry about the long-term response, both domestically and abroad, I'm angry that there are people who would happily do the same thing again, and I'm angry that my feelings make me, in the eyes of the administration, an abettor of terrorism. I've been angry every single day for the last five years, and today is no different.

And that's really all I can say.
Remembering the Trifecta, at The Agonist, who dug up an older story to remind us all:
. . . . Professional stand-up comedians know that Sept. 11 jokes are radioactive. Not even the bravest have tried to turn the deaths of some 3,000 people into a laughing matter. But President Bush has forged ahead anyway. Bush has now been telling the same, spectacularly tasteless joke to a variety of mostly Republican audiences as part of his stock stump speech . . . .Bush appears to give "trifecta" a sort of rueful, ironic meaning. But therein also lies the morbid edge: After all, Bush -- who in the weeks preceding the tragedy faced mounting questions about his ability as well as his legitimacy, all of which vanished afterward -- is possibly the only American for whom Sept. 11 was indeed a stroke of incredible good fortune. However, the real problem with the joke is that it is a complete falsehood. (read it all)
Joe Bagent on Madmen and Sedatives:
. . . . Some days however, change does seem to be afoot, as it certainly must be, given that change is the world's only constant. A majority of Americas now disapprove of the war in Iraq. Just three years ago when I started writing from this town's taverns and churches, working people therein absolutely loved George Bush. Now they have returned to their normal state of political apathy, seldom speaking of Bush, but with one difference -- they no longer approve of his war, and express disapproval generally in the form of grumbling. They grumble because television has given them permission to do so, through its constant touting of polling results expressing "dissatisfaction" with the war. Being "dissatisfied" with something, a war in this case, is more in accordance with their programming as consumers, not citizens. They will never get permission to be really pissed off, much less pissed off enough to burn anything down. . . . (experience the whole thing)
Firestarter5 says it with a bumpersticker (which Blogger will not let me upload at the moment), and Blue Wren in verse.

John Micek on where he was, and where we have gone since then:
. . . .But there in the sadness and the silence, we vividly remember thinking that there was a quiet hope -- that this might finally be the opportunity for us to get it together as a species and transcend the petty (and ultimately meaningless) differences that separate us.

Of course, there were those who felt otherwise -- as we've since seen.
And this morning, we wake to a nation -- and a world -- that's as polarized as it's ever been.

We use artificial labels (gay/straight, liberal/conservative, Christian/non-Christian, Republican/Democrat, legal immigrant/illegal immigrant) to define ourselves away from others, instead of recognizing all that we share -- notably, common DNA, our hope in our children, and, of course, the fact that we're all stuck on this rock whether we want to be or not.

So, instead of remembering the sadness of that day this morning, we're instead going to remember the hope we felt in the quiet that came after it, and the opportunity we had to finally get things right.

And we will pray that we somehow find our way back to it.
Because if we don't, then those deaths will have truly been in vain. . . . (there's more)
Ol' Froth wonders, as do we all, Where's Osama?

The Rittenhouse Review on why their phones will go unanswered today:
I tire now of those who want me, and us, to remember where we where then. I'm sorry, but it doesn't matter where I was then, and the same holds for the vast majority of us. Look, if you weren't in the World Trade Center -- trying to get the hell out -- or in the Pentagon or on one of the planes that crashed, or were one of the first/second/third responders to those sites, or you lost your spouse/partner/parent/child there, really, what difference does it make where we were? You lost, I lost, they lost. Most important: They -- the They, they -- lost. They are dead. (Read it all)
PSoTD on The Saddest Day of the Year:
We mourn the loss of so many innocent souls on September 11. But as time goes on, it feels like we're mourning the loss of our country's health as well. We shouldn't accept it as permanent. We have to find a way to get better as a nation. What we're doing is not working. After five years, we have to start trying some new strategies. And in order to do that, we have to accept new leaders. Our nation, more than anything, needs hope again. Today it seems that hope is flickering, an old candle greatly in need of replacement. We need hope that shines brightly like a roaring bonfire, beckoning all to warm themselves at the edge. We need leaders that can inspire such hope. (There's more)
Bernie simply suggests that we Google "failure". As do I.

I Live in Delaware County suggests viewing "9/11: Press for Truth". As do I.

Our Luck Has Run Out

On September 12, 2001, the world was with us. Even Iran and Qaddafi were extending offers of assistance. Our long-time friends, like France, were ready to follow us into Hell if that would help. The Bush Administration's ham-handed manipulation and cement-headed diplomacy quickly turned most of the world from our blood compatriots into, at best, disgusted neutrals, and at worst, active antagonists. Whether through ineptitude, stupidity, or malice, the Bush Administration failed to address the real causes of the terrorist attacks five years ago. Instead, these frat-boys with too-powerful toys scratched their balls, beat their chests, and declared freedom the enemy of the terrorists. Dutifully, they set to work to dismantle that freedom, presumably to reduce the target.

But, let's go back twenty-four hours.

President Bush has just spent the night at an exclusive resort in Florida. Surface-to-air missiles are on the roof of the resort. Shortly after 6 am, a van with four men said to be of Middle Eastern descent arrives at the resort, claiming to have arranged an interview with Bush. They are turned away.

According to the 9-11 Commission Report, at 8:32, a flight attendant uses an Airphone to contact American Airlines and report that Flight 11 has been hijacked. The conversation lasts for 12 minutes. Among the details she provides are that the hijackers appear to be of Middle East descent, have stormed the cockpit and that it appears that the pilots are no longer flying the plane. She says that they have a bomb, have stabbed two other attendants and killed one passenger.

At 8:35 am, Bush leaves the resort for a twenty minute ride to an elementary school for a Photo Op. Two minutes later, according to the Commission Report, NORAD is notified that Flight 11 has been hijacked and has turned towards NYC; the FAA requests that fighter jets be scrambled.

At 8:46 Flight 11 hits WTC Tower 1. Accounts are conflicting over when Bush was finally told. Some have him being told while on his limo ride, others immediately upon his arrival at the school at 8:55. He has said (several times) that he saw the video of the first plan hitting the tower on a TV right before he entered the classroom. This is untrue as the first video was not aired until late that evening. In any event, everyone agrees that Bush was told that the plane had struck the tower before he went into the classroom. What else Bush was told is the subject of varying reports.

At about 9:01, Cheney turned on the television to watch the coverage of the first plane strike when, at 9:03 he witnessed the second strike. At 9:05, Andrew Card told the President “A second plane hit the second tower. America is under attack.” (Most of this narrative is taken from the Commission Report, which you can search here.) What happened next deserves to be seen in it's painful entirety.

Very soon after the first attack, I had received a call from a friend who told me to put on CNN. I did and called the rest of the office into the conference room -- many of us had long contacts with NYC and knew people in the Towers and the area. We all witnessed the second plane hit. Before the President picked up "My Pet Goat" we were on the phone to friends and relatives in the area and had a discussion about the likely sources of the attack. By the time that the President was talking to the students at a podium in the school, we had closed the office for the day, cancelled appointments, and sent everyone home to be with their families and in touch with loved ones and friends in New York. Unbeknownst to me at the time, a cousin's son was at that moment climbing the stairs in Tower 1, a NYC firefighter off that day, he reported to the scene without being called. He was never seen again.

All the while, my President stood stock still at 9 am. Then he scurried around the country, hiding and occasionally peeking out from under his covers.

Five years later, our long-standing alliances are shaken and bent, the potential for new alliances is broken, our vulnerability to terrorist attack is unchanged, the recommendations of the 9-11 Commission (itself resisted by Bush) are all but ignored, and our civil liberties under attack by our own Government.

Imagine where we could be today had we had a real leader, a person of vision and history, leading an executive branch of talent and expertise. Over the course of our history, we have been fortunate to have such people at the fore exactly when we needed them -- Franklin, Adams, Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln. Our luck has run out.

Sunday, September 10, 2006

Casey Campaign Says Desperate Santorum Behind False Poll Rumor

On Friday, a new Pennsylvania blog claimed to have a source who had a source who said an internal Casey Poll showed the race closing to within the margin of error, with Santorum at 44% and Casey at 47%. The rumor was dutifully crowed o'er by the Santorum-supporting blogs (PoliPundit, SantorumBlog, RedState, Right Side of the Rainbow, DeSales for Rick) and whined o'er by the Casey supporters, with both sides treating it as fact.

Our initial reaction was dubious, for a number of reasons. So, calling on our long-ago, done and buried, journalism career, we simply put it to the Casey camp. An e-mail to Larry Smar, Casey's campaign chief spokesperson [haste makes waste -- just noticed I left out "spokesperson" here -- Jay Reiff is Casey's campaign manager, Larry Smar the press guy -- ABFS], was promptly returned. Smar denied that there was any such internal and put the source of the rumor on a desperate Santorum campaign which has been mired at or below 40% despite an early and expensive ad buy:
You should know that you can't believe everything you read on blogs. There isn't a shred of truth to that post.

Ever[] since Gallup/USA Today published a poll last week showing us again leading by double digits, the Santorum camp has been in spin overdrive. First, Santorum told MSNBC that is was a "bogus poll."

Next, the NRSC reheated a leftover press release rehashing old polls to claim Santorum was surging--ignoring the latest numbers to the contrary. Nobody bought it. Now they are shopping around a right-wing blog post about some bogus internal Casey poll.

It is important to note that the Gallup poll was the first public poll released since we started our ad buy.

So Santorum and his allies have aired $7 million in TV ads. The third-party groups that have been spending millions helping Santorum are now required to be off the air. It looks like Santorum has blown most of his cash-on-hand advantage. And we still have a double-digit lead and Santorum's numbers are still anchored at or below 40%.

No wonder Santorum is calling Gallup polls bogus and making up fake Casey polls.
Smar makes a number of noteworthy points here. As we said a couple of weeks back, Santorum's inability to move out of the upper thirties/low forties in polling negates any Republican claim of a momentum for the flailing incumbent. The fact that, after almost two months of early advertising, Santorum's team has been unable to move his numbers up is rather telling. If Smar is correct about the size of Santorum's ad buys -- $7 million -- then the Senator has indeed blown his cash-on-hand lead. As of June 30, Santorum's reported cash on hand was $9.4 million, against Bob Casey's reported $5.4 million. The loss of the cash advantage, combined with the loss of non-candidate-based advertising 60-days out from the election, could make for some desperate times for Santorum.

The Senator is much further from winning this campaign than the 6 or 8-point gaps in some recent polls suggest. He is a multi-term incumbent, stuck at or below 40, is consistently rated by Pennsylvanians lower than nearly all other US Senators, has terrible unfavorables, and has been joined at the hip to a Bush Adminstration which gets some of its lowest marks from PA voters. If, in addition to all of that, he has blown his huge cash advantage . . . . get the butter, Mabel, the toast is almost ready.

Saturday, September 09, 2006

Casey Internal Polls Said to Show Race Within MOE

Supposedly, a Casey Campaign internal poll now shows him leading Senator Santorum 47-44%. This report comes from a Pennsylvania blogger who says that the information comes from a source not inside the Casey camp, who supposedly heard it from a Casey insider in Washington. [sarcasm] Despite the outstanding provenance of the information [/sarcasm], I have some doubts.

The report claims that the Santorum rise and Casey drop was the result of the recent Meet the Press meet-up. That's dubious. I have not seen the Nielsens, but I would be shocked if a meaningful number of potential Pennsylvania voters watched the broadcast. The media coverage of the event largely agreed that there wasn't any winner to the face-off and that both men held their own. Also, I would expect that the Santorum internal pollings would be similar to the purported Casey numbers. If that were the case, the Santorum team would be leaking their polling all over the place, and that hasn't happened.

It will be interesting to see if the Casey campaign denies the report.

Thursday, September 07, 2006

Is Santorum Mixing Campaign and Senate Office Data?

At the outset of the Pennsylvania Senate Race, I signed up at the Santorum website in order to gain access to the information there. Among other things, when I signed up, I was asked to identify the issues in which I had an interest. Among them, I listed the environment.

While I corresponded with Senator Santorum's office prior to this election cycle -- never that I recall on any environmental issue. I have written to him with respect to military pay issues, blood diamonds, civil rights, and flag-burning. Other than the flag-burning and miltary pay, all other correspondence was at least two years ago. I never before received a spontaneous e-mail from my junior Senator.

Yet, today, I received from his Senate Office -- not the campaign mind you, but his Senate Office -- an email beginning "Knowing of your interest in preserving our Commonwealth's environment". Now, unless in addition to all of his other powers, the Senator is claiming to be psychic, the only communication which I have had with him indicating my interest in the environment was through his campaign website.

The Senate Ethics Manual has an extensive chapter on this sort of thing, and makes it pretty clear that mixing campaign information with Senate resources is a no-no:
Title 31 of the United States Code, section 1301(a) states that ‘‘appropriations shall be applied only to the objects for which the appropriations were made except as otherwise provided by law.’’ This principle of federal appropriations law has been interpreted in Congress to mean that congressional employees receive publicly funded salaries for performance of official duties and, therefore, campaign or other non-official activities should not take place on Senate time, using Senate equipment or facilities. . . . Senate employees are compensated from funds of the Treasury for regular performance of official duties. They are not paid to do campaign work. In the words of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia: ‘‘It is clear from the record that Congress has recognized the basic principle that government funds should not be spent to help incumbents gain reelection.’’
Since the combination of my e-mail address and interest in the environment could only have been found in the campaign database, I've got to conclude that there's been some mixing of purposes going on here. It may or may not have technically violated Senate Rules. But it sure doesn't smell good.

I had a similar experience with Republican Senate Candidate Katherine Harris. Way back when she first decided to run for the US House, I received an e-mail from her announcing her candidacy. The e-mail said that my address had been obtained from prior communications with Ms. Harris.

The only prior communications that I had with Ms. Harris had been when she interfered with Democracy, as Secretary of State. You might recall that -- that was when Gore beat Bush but not the Supreme Court. In a reply to the Harris announcement, I wondered aloud about the propriety of the partisan use of the property of the State of Florida (the Secretary's offical correspondence files) in her campaign. I didn't hear from her again.

I'm just sayin' . . . .

Wednesday, September 06, 2006

ABFS - Destination of the Day

ABFS was selected as the "Pennsylvania Destination of the Day" for September 5 by About Pennsylvania.

Yay, me.

Monday, September 04, 2006

Yankees Win -- Casey Strikes Out

I had tickets to yesterday afternoon's Yankees game against the Minnesota Twins (the result of sitting through a couple of hours of rain on Old Timer's Day before the game was called before the Yankees came to bat). Tori Hunter hit a monster homer run on an early mistake by Rasner, the Yankees' rookie pitcher, called up from the Clippers to provide an extra arm needed due to the doubleheader on Wednesday. But other than the second inning pitch to Hunter, Rasner had a solid outing, going 6, giving up but four hits, one run, and no walks. On the otehr side of the ball, A-Rod blasted two homeruns, Abreu had three doubles, and the (previously) vaunted Minnesota bullpen could not withstand the Yankee offensive power, giving up 8 of the home teams ten runs before (yet another) sell out crowd at The Stadium on a gorgeous, 70-ish, mostly-sunny afternoon in the Home Office of Baseball.

Meanwhile, in Washington, Bob Casey and Rick Santorum had their first face off of the campaign, sitting across the desk from the cherubic, over-rated, lawyer cum political operative cum softball interviewer Tim Russert. Because of the travel-time to The Stadium, our party was on the road well before the airing of MTP. I have purposefully avoided looking at the commentary and blogs on the debate until I had chance to cue up the online replay of the event this morning.

I've done so and have to say that I am disappointed in Casey's performance. (Perhaps the "Casey Strikes Out" heading was too harsh -- but it fit in with the baseball themed opening. Casey more like bunted.) I had been hoping that his staff had adequately prepared him to be something more than just Bobby Casey for this much-anticipated initial encounter with the dark side of the political universe.

Alas, I was hoping for too much. Before looking at some specifics, I found Casey came off as (all-too-typically) short on substance, shorter on ideas, and even shorter still on specifics. He didn't lay a glove on Santorum (although Russert did), while Santorum effectively countered most of Casey's mumbled talking points and followed those up with a few sharp jabs and body blows.

On substance, Santorum was way off base and disconnected from reality. In delivery and demeanor, Santorum mostly looked strong, in control, confident, and self-assured, Casey none of those things. Santorum wore a dark suit, white shirt, deep red tie. Casey (who showed up for the first primary debate looking like he had just stepped off a private country club golf course), wore a dark suit, white shirt and, appropriately, a
pale blue tie (he also wore an American Flag lapel pin -- I guess so that we all understood that he was an American).

Iraq -- Santorum: 'Stay THE Course' vs. Casey: 'Stay OF Course'

From the start, Casey demonstrated his weakness -- Russert began by recounting Casey's statements in support of the Iraq war. As recently as the Democratic primary debates, Bob Casey said that he was in favor of staying the course in Iraq -- he was opposed to a timetable, opposed to pulling the troops out of Iraq, and in favor of staying until the mission was accomplished. During the primary debates, he declined the opportunity to say that the vote authorizing the Iraq war was a mistake. Russert gave him another opportunity to join those Democratic Senators who have said that their vote on Iraq was a mistake. He didn't answer the question and Russert let him slide.
MR. RUSSERT: Let’s go right to it: the war in Iraq. Mr. Casey, you’re the challenger, you told The Philadelphia Inquirer August 2005 the following:

“Casey said he would have voted for the war considering the evidence at the time, and supported the spending bills that funded the effort.” Knowing what you know today, would you still have voted for the war?

MR. CASEY: (After condolences to Pittsburgh Mayor Bob O'Connor's family) Tim, on the war in Iraq, if, if, if a lot of Americans knew now—if they knew then what they know now, they would, they would have thought that this war was the war that shouldn’t have been fought based upon the misleading of this administration. . . .

MR. RUSSERT: So you would not vote for it today.

MR. CASEY: Based upon the information that we have now, I think that, that a lot of Americans would have serious doubts. I’m not sure there would have even been a vote on Iraq that early in the...

MR. RUSSERT: But in ‘05 you said you’d vote for it. Would you today in ‘06 vote for it?

MR. CASEY: Based upon the evidence that was presented then, yes, which I think has been—was misleading, and I think it was faulty. The intelligence was faulty.

MR. RUSSERT: But today, today is no. Today you would vote no.

MR. CASEY: Today—if we knew then what we know now, sure. I think there wouldn’t have been a vote and I think people would have changed.

Russert only pretended to press him for a direct response to a direct question -- "If he knew then what we know now, would he have voted to authorize the Iraq war?"

Casey ducked it. He talked about how the "American people" wouldn't support the war, how "if a lot of Americans knew now—if they knew then what they know now, they would, they would have thought that this war was the war that shouldn’t have been fought". What Russert should have said was, 'Mr. Casey we all know how the American people feel about the war, what the people of Pennsylvania deserve to know is how Bob Casey feels about it. So I'd like to ask you again, yes or no Mr. Casey, if you knew then what you know now, would you have voted in favor of the Iraq war?'

This is a top issue on the minds of every voter in America and we in Pennsylvania deserve an answer from Casey. Casey lacks the courage to state clearly his position and that came through at the very start of the joint appearance on MTP. It was not a good start. It got a little worse right away.

After saying that he would not vote to cut off funding because "I’m not ready to abandon this mission", Casey made sounds like he was about -- for the first time I can recall -- to give some specifics on what he would do in Iraq. But, I forgot that this was merely a politician, not a leader, and, after saying that there were "a couple of things" we need, then saying that he would list "four or five", he listed three, or maybe four, but only one specific, I think:
One of them is a question of accountability. . . . Accountability, I think, means replacing Donald Rumsfeld . . . . The second thing we need, I think, in Iraq, in terms of a new direction is to make sure that we have clear and measurable benchmarks. And thirdly, I think what’s happening in Iraq should tell us that we need to transform the mission on the ground. . . . The Iraqis need to take over and take on some of these street patrols, patrols in Baghdad and so many other places. And I think also, Tim, I’ll conclude with this: We need to rebuild the American military. We need to have more Special Forces. I’ve called for a doubling in the number of Special Forces.
You see, I was hoping to hear something like, "Well, Tim, what I would do is put together a three-pronged approach to the problem. First, we need to recognize the mistakes we made in how we went into the war. We need to go back to the world community and say we have a problem in the mid-east and that problem is not just a US problem -- if unresolved it could affect world politics and stability for generations. We need a new approach, a world-approach. I would invite the world to propose solutions. We need to understand how our go-it-alone strategy has alienated so many of our natural allies and we need to work on bringing them back into the picture. Second, Tim, we need to recognize how the credibility of the United States has been hurt -- even among our friends in the Arab world. We need to invite the Arab league into the negotiations and into Iraq. Sure, American troops need to stay and provide support and border security. But the face of the occupied Iraq needs to be more multi-national, needs to be Arabic, if we are to convince the Iraqis and the rest of the Arab world that our mission there is not to secure a US presence and dominance over a significant source of energy in the middle east. And third, we need a real Marshall Plan to rebuild the infrastructure of Iraq. Not by awarding no-bid contracts to Haliburton, but by engaging the community of nations and pledging hundreds of billions of dollars to getting the electricity and running water back on -- Tim, are you aware that 90% of Iraq does not have daily electricity and water yet? That is outrageous and it is our fault."

What came after "Well, Tim" hardly mattered -- I wanted to hear some higher-level thinking on the problem and a proposal of concrete solutions.

Instead, we got an answer which disappointingly sounds very much like 'stay the course' (oh, and "double the special forces"). Huh?

Was there any game plan going into this?

Didn't Casey understand that Russert would start with Iraq?

Didn't they think about a way to deliver an early, strong, Senatorial message -- offer a stark contrast with Santorum's strong support of the Bush war on Iraq?

Couldn't they come up with a bold declaration of the failures of the Bush/Santorum policies and the bankruptcy of ideas coming from Washington?

Couldn't they have come up with a way to use Iraq to put Rick Santorum on the defensive right at the start?

Here was there big plan (I guess it was planned), right after Casey gets done with his no-specifics, non-statement on Iraq, he challenges Santorum to disavow Rumsfeld (and lsater, he would ask him to disavow Cheney). Gee, I just hope that no one on the Casey side thought that Santorum would be surprised by this and wouldn't have a strong response at the ready. If they did think that, then I hate to see how they are going to handle the real debates.

Instead of putting Santorum on the defensive, Casey handed him an opportunity to turn the discussion into his Islamic Facists nonsense. It may be nonsense to thinking people, but it has been resonating with the electorate, mainly because of the false linking of the administration's failures in Iraq with the nuclear threat posed by Iran:
MR. CASEY: . . . .And I would just ask Senator Santorum: Donald Rumsfeld, I’ve called for him to be replaced, Rick. Where do you stand on that?

SEN. SANTORUM: I’ll be happy to start there. I think Secretary Rumsfeld has done a fine job as the defense secretary, and the problems that we are confronting are problems of an enemy that’s a very potent enemy—much more potent than I think anybody ever anticipated. You know, we have a great game plan. We go it just like a football team. You go in there, you do your best, but the enemy has a vote, the enemy can react and change its tactics, and they have, and they’ve been very, very effective. We need to go out there and continue to fight this war on Islamic fascism. Not just, as my opponent likes to focus on, just the war in Iraq. That’s a front of a multi-front war in which we’re fighting against an enemy that’s a very dangerous enemy. . . . So we have a very difficult enemy. We have an enemy that now is trying to get nuclear weapons in, in, in the form of Iran, and one that—you know, we can ask all these questions about process and procedure, most of which I would argue have been answered already. The real tough questions is how do you win this war? How do you go out and, and, and prosecute a war that—successfully? And I’ve laid out a very clear vision on that, and my opponent has not.

That last phrase hung in the air (and was an effectively-repeated theme). Casey never responded to it.

Russert was more prepared than Casey. He immediately cited the report (released late Friday before a holiday weekend), which labeled sectarian fighting as a larger problem in Iraq than terrorists -- in other words, 'No, Rick, even your own Pentagon says we are not fighting them over there, we are reaping the fruit of our own incompetence.'
MR. RUSSERT: Let me talk about a Pentagon report on Friday. Our ambassador to Iraq has said the principal problem is not foreign terrorists, it’s sectarian violence, Sunni vs. Shiite. The Pentagon report on Friday said this: “Sectarian violence is spreading in Iraq and the security problems have become more complex than at any time since the U.S. invasion in 2003, a Pentagon report said. ... ‘Death squads and terrorists are locked in mutually reinforcing cycles of sectarian strife.’ ... ‘The last quarter, as you know has been rough,’ [Asst. Secretary of Defense Peter] Rodman said. ‘The levels of violence are up and the sectarian quality of the violence is particularly acute and disturbing.’”

This is Shiite vs. Sunni, Iraqi vs. Iraqi. . . . What do you do about that, stay the course?

Santorum tried to move the question back to his Islamofacist argument, but Russert stopped him with a point that Casey was unable to make -- that the Bush policy created the opportunity for Iran to leverage the influence it has been developing in Iraq for over twenty years:

SEN. SANTORUM: . . . . And Iran, which is, which is the principal stoker of this, this Shia/Sunni sectarian violence, would love nothing more to see than the Iraqi democracy fail because of that. This is a tactic of Iran to disrupt the—our, our efforts in Iraq by, in fact, trying to defeat the Sunnis. So there’s, there’s no question, this is a very complex war.

. . . .But understand, at the, at the heart of this war is Iran. Iran is the, is, is the problem here. Iran is the one that’s causing most of the problems in, in Iraq. It is causing most of the problems, obviously, with Israel today. It is, it is the one funding these organizations. And is the, is the country that we need to focus on in this war against Islamic fascism.

MR. RUSSERT: So Iran now has more influence in Iraq than they did before Saddam Hussein?

SEN. SANTORUM: Just understand.

MR. RUSSERT: Is that true?

SEN. SANTORUM: I would say that they have influence in, in, in a free country where you have an opportunity to express yourself, if you will. Yes.
(Santorum looked bad here.) Soon after this exchange, Santorum looked just silly trying to defend his claim that the weapons we went to war over were found in Iraq.
MR. RUSSERT: Senator Santorum, leading up to the war. In October of 2002, this is what Rick Santorum said, “Saddam Hussein’s regime, is a serious and grave danger to the safety of the American people.” “Given the threat posed to he world by his weapons of mass destruction programs...” Would you now acknowledge that that was not correct?

SEN. SANTORUM: What I would say is that we have found weapons of mass destruction, they were older weapons, but we have found chemical weapons. The report was just released not too long ago that, that said that there were over 500 chemical weapons found in Iraq.

MR. RUSSERT: Senator, the president has accepted the report of his two task force and said, “That the chief weapons inspector has issued his report. Iraq did not have the weapons our intelligence believed were there.”

SEN. SANTORUM: Well, there were all sorts of weapons that our intelligence believed were there. They thought that they were new weapons. So far we, we did not—we have not found any new weapons. But we have found old weapons, weapons from the Iran/Iraq conflict, and we found over 500 and the report says that there were more.

Santorum continued with the (thoroughly debunked) argument that Bin Laden and Saddam were working together prior to 9/11, saying that "we have certainly lots of information about the fact that they were working with other terrorist organizations, including al-Qaeda". This a major weakness of Santorum's support for Iraq which Casey should be hitting all over the park -- that Santorum is making ridiculous claims which even the President has rejected, that Santorum is way out there, that he is even further divorced from the reality of Iraq than this misguided adminstration.

Instead, when Casey interrupts and asks for a chance to make a point, he walks right into Russert's prep, seemingly like no one had prepared Casey to deal with it:
MR. CASEY: ...let me respond to that. Can I have a few minutes to respond?

MR. RUSSERT: Please.

MR. CASEY: Couple of things. First of all, what you just heard was Senator Santorum’s long answer, which basically says, “Stay the course in Iraq.” It’s a completely different point of view. I think we’ve go got to change the course and, and have new leadership. Part of that is that, that accountability I’ve talked about.

MR. RUSSERT: But stop there—stop there Mr. Casey.

MR. CASEY: OK.

MR. RUSSERT: I think there’s an evolution in your thinking. Let me go back to April of ‘05, the Philadelphia Daily News said, “The key thing now is to finish the job.” That’s Bob Casey, quote/unquote. October, “Some people think that pulling out is a good idea and a timeline is a good idea - I don’t agree with that. We’ve got more work to do to make sure that we get it right.” Then in June of ‘06, Bob Casey said, “He doesn’t believe U.S. troops should be removed from Iraq immediately but should be by the end of the year. He said the country has a new government and that it’s time for the Iraqis to take a greater role in defending themselves.” Should we finished the job? Or should we remove the troops by the end of the year?

MR. CASEY: Tim, I’ve never favored a deadline in, in, in this whole campaign. Because we have to do everything we can to, to hold the administration accountable. And when you’re—when it’s not going well, you, you see the, the Pentagon report this past—just in the last couple of days, this thing is headed toward civil war. We don’t know if it’s there yet. We hope it’s not. But when you have it heading in the wrong direction, you’ve got to have a new course. And, and...

MR. RUSSERT: So, so when John Kerry, the Democratic nominee in 2004, introduced legislation which says, “All troops out by July of 2007,” Bob Casey votes no.

MR. CASEY: Absolutely.

So, instead of being able to call Santorum out on his faulty rationale for going into and staying in Iraq, Casey gets called out on his own inspecific, shifting positions and refusing to set a goal of getting us out of Iraq in 2007. Instead, what Casey seems to offer us is "stay a little different course".

Iraq took up a significant part of the MTP hour. But at no point did Casey lay a glove on Santorum. He let Santorum spew indefensible arguments for what we did and what we are continuing to do. Even when he started to make what sounding like a decent, somewhat original point about using special forces to ferret out nuclear weapons technology on the black market, Russert stopped him in his tracks with yet another obvious question which Casey seemed unprepared to answer.
MR. CASEY: Tim, you’re hearing, you’re hearing a long speech here about, about other speeches he’s given. What we need and what the president needs to tell us about, and what this senator won’t hold the president accountable for is a plan. One of the things that we could be doing, not just when it comes to Iraq, but when it comes to the, the global war on terror, is to have more Special Forces out there. Doubling the number of Special Forces, having counterproliferation units run by the Special Forces that intercept nuclear, biological, chemical, potential weapons around the world—finding them before the terrorists get them. That’s the kind of on-the-ground thing. We don’t need more speeches.

And I think what you’ve unearthed here, Tim...

MR. RUSSERT: Do we need more troops?

MR. CASEY: We need—what we need in Iraq right now is some accountability for this administration. And part of that is making sure that, as we, as we have our troops on the ground, that they can pull back at what the Pentagon calls “level two” readiness, they can still be there, but the Iraqis can take the lead and get the Americans out of the front line already. Keep the American...(unintelligible).

MR. RUSSERT: And what if you, what if you left behind a haven for terrorists? Then what do you do?

MR. CASEY: Well, I don’t—that’s not the, that’s not the, the objective here. The objective here is to make sure we’re doing everything possible to give the American people the information they need and to protect our troops. And I think it’s an abomination, Tim, when you have people like Rick Santorum, who have rubber-stamped this administration 98 percent of the time, did not call for or insist upon the best body armor when those troops needed it.

Weak. It should not have been that hard to prepare for this appearance and for the Iraq issue. He should have anticipated every question from Russert and every issue and had solid responses -- Santorum certainly did. And, even if Santorum's responses were not defendable, they were clearly prepared in advance and Casey failed to effectively counter them. Combined with a failure to effectively lay out a clear alternative on Iraq, the Iraq portion of the discussion went, inexplicably, to Santorum.

On Illegal Wiretapping -- Casey Agrees with Santorum

Santorum maneuvered the discussion to the illegal wiretapping programs that the Bush Adminstration secretly undertook. In response, Casey declined the opportunity to talk about a nation of laws, about respecting and incorporating the freedoms that Iraqis didn't have under Sadaam in every aspect of our government. Nope, instead, Casey lined right up with the Republicans in supporting the administration's surveillance programs and didn't even challenge Santorum's baseless assertion that the illegal programs were the foundation for the British interception of the terrorist plots to blow up airplanes over the Atlantic:
MR. CASEY: . . . .Let me, let me just have a moment on, on Iran. Rick, you just talked about, and you’ve heard him a lot talking about Iran. You’ve heard him a lot talking about the terminology of, of the war on terror. He calls it Islamic fascism and, and he, and he talks about the terminology and changing the terms. What we need, Rick, is not a change in the terminology, we need to change the tactics. And we’ve got to make sure that even as you’re debating whether or not we call Osama bin Laden a terrorist or a fascist, I don’t think that really matters. We need a plan. You’re in the Senate, you have votes, you should be leading that effort. And I, I think after it’s over, after you get the terminology right, maybe you can have a seminar in Washington about whether bin Laden, whom we should be finding and killing, whether he’s a dead terrorist or a dead fascist. And I think you should worry more about finding him and killing him.

SEN. SANTORUM: My, my opponent has, my opponent has, my opponent has no plan. The idea—all he’s suggested is his plan is Special...

MR. CASEY: I just gave a plan. Where’s yours?

SEN. SANTORUM: All you, all you suggested with your plan is more Special Forces.

MR. CASEY: No, it’s not. That’s not, that’s not all it is.

SEN. SANTORUM: Do you, do you support, do you support more intelligence gathering because your party has been out there...

MR. CASEY: Absolutely.

SEN. SANTORUM: ...trying to, trying to undermine our surveillance programs. You’re the one who’s gone out and said that you have serious questions about our intelligence surveillance programs. What do you think has kept our people safe? What do you think stopped the British, the British attack? You folks have been the party, as you have been the party, of making sure that we don’t have the intelligence gathering capabilities that we need, and, and, and have, have joined in making sure...

MR. CASEY: Rick, Rick, you’re not debating the party, you’re debating me right here.

SEN. SANTORUM: I’m debating you.

MR. CASEY: Yeah.

SEN. SANTORUM: And I—and I’ve looked at your comments saying that you have serious concerns about our, our, our surveillance programs. I don’t. I think they’re surveillance programs that would...

MR. CASEY: No, we should, we should, we should keep the programs and keep the wiretaps...

Not the kind of response that we look for from a Democratic challenger -- agreeing with Santorum and the Republican right.

Military Option on Iran -- Santorum Favors Sanctions, Casey Favors Sanctions

In response to Russert's direct question, Santorum gave a direct response -- he does not favor a military option in Iran. Well, sort of. He wants us to foment rebellion in Iran and foment military pressure from other "pro-democracy forces outside [Iran]". Well, there's something which the United States has a lot of credibility in -- encouraging nationals to rise up against their oppressive regimes (sarcasm alert). But instead of challenging Santorum's "plan" for Iran as making no sense (and almost no one believes that it does), Casey jumped on the Sanctions bandwagon and supported Santorum's Iran bill.

Casey himself has a little problem here -- during the Democratic primary debates he stated his support for using nuclear weapons on Iran in order to stop their nuclear development program. Russert's crack staff apparently failed to turn that one up and Russert never mentioned it. But Casey could have come off strong here by attacking Santorum's assumptions about fomenting democratic revolutions in the region (it worked soooo well in Iraq, twice) (irony alert).

Conclusion

Half the MTP appearance focused on Iraq -- it should have been softball after softball issue for Bob Casey. But Casey never made solid contact with the ball. Part of the reason was that he was poorly prepped by his staff, part of it was that he has an aversion to taking definable positions, and part of it is that he doesn't appear to have a very solid understanding of the issues. The remainder of the program was similar -- on balancing the budget and social security, for example, Russert was very frustrated by Casey's continued refusal inability to provide specifics.

At the end of the day, MTP was a warm-up. Casey didn't lose, Santyorum didn't win. Santorum did better than he should have because Casey didn't do nearly as well as a strong Democratic challenger could have (Casey did better than he did in the Democratic primary debates, in which both of his opponents ran circles around him on policy and debate points.) But, not many "real" people tuned in early Sunday morning on a holiday weekend to see this showdown.

Recall that Howard Dean's first appearance on the program was a disaster which was quickly forgotten as he improved as a national-scene candidate. He hit homerun after homerun on his next appearance. One can hope that Casey can do likewise -- he's got plenty of time before the real debates in October. In the meantime, he needs to focus on distinguishing himself from Santorum and less time on finding common ground with one of the lowest-rated Senators. I am hopeful that someone in the Casey campaign will send him a memo on why Santorum has got such a high disapproval rating in Pennsylvania.